PhilaNova

Why do we give?To belong.

A free, open guide to the oldest human habit: seven reasons people give, the evidence behind each one, and the people who found it.

Seven reasons people give, and the evidence for each.

Most givers have three or four of these at once. Choose a reason to see what the reason is, what the research found, the numbers behind it, and who found it.

The seven reasons are PhilaNova's own grouping, drawn from about 400 sources. Its backbone is the eight mechanisms of giving set out by Bekkers and Wiepking, Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 2011 (opens the source). Each reason carries an evidence grade: Strong, Moderate, Weak or Contested.

Belong1Say whoI am2Give back3Beremembered4Know itworks5Be seen,or not6Feel theglow7

Choose a reason, or use the arrow keys.

Reason 1 of 7

Belong

Evidence: Moderate

“We do this together.”

What it is

Giving to and with the people we belong to: family, faith, neighbours, a circle of friends. The gift is also the glue that holds them together.

Key numbers

$1.29bn

granted by US giving circles, which tripled in number from 2007

Lilly Family School of Philanthropy, 2017 (opens the source)
150,000+

people have taken part in giving circles, in all 50 US states

Lilly Family School of Philanthropy, 2017 (opens the source)
1,244

teenagers studied: parents' example and parents' words both mattered

Ottoni-Wilhelm, Estell and Perdue, 2014 (opens the source)

The evidence

Who found it

More about giving, one chapter at a time.

From the first gift to the foundation.

Small children help strangers before they can talk (Warneken and Tomasello, Science, 2006 (opens the source)). Everything since has been culture shaping that urge into rules.

  1. Deep past

    Kin, favours, a good name

    Evolution favoured helping family, trading favours and earning a reputation for generosity.

    Hamilton, Journal of Theoretical Biology, 1964 (opens the source) · Trivers, Quarterly Review of Biology, 1971 (opens the source) · Nowak and Sigmund, Nature, 1998 (opens the source)
  2. 7th c.

    Zakat and the waqf

    Islam made giving a duty, and the waqf endowment let a gift serve a purpose for centuries.

    The Qur'an, Surah 9:60, 7th c. (opens the source) · Kuran, Law and Society Review, 2001 (opens the source)
  3. 1050

    A family charity estate

    Fan Zhongyan set up land whose income supported his whole lineage, an early family foundation.

    Joseph McDermott, The ancestral hall as a financial institution in China, 2018 (opens the source)
  4. c. 1132

    The almshouse

    The Hospital of St Cross in Winchester fed the poor at its gate, and it is still running today.

    Historic Houses, The Hospital of St Cross: history (opens the source)
  5. 12th c.

    A ladder of giving

    Maimonides ranked eight ways to give. The top one is helping someone become self-reliant.

    Maimonides, Mishneh Torah, Gifts to the Poor 10:7–14, 12th c. (opens the source)
  6. 1601

    What counts as charity

    An English statute listed charitable purposes. Courts across the common-law world still trace their definitions to it.

    Malik, Defining charity and charitable purposes in the UK, 2008 (opens the source)
  7. 1863

    Geneva and the Red Cross

    Henry Dunant and four others met in Geneva. A year later came the first Geneva Convention.

    International Committee of the Red Cross, Our history, 1863 (opens the source)
  8. 1869

    “Scientific” charity

    London's Charity Organisation Society tried to measure and vet need. The critique that vetting can humiliate began here too.

    Skinner and Thomas, Children and Society, 2018 (opens the source)
  9. 1889

    The Gospel of Wealth

    Andrew Carnegie argued the rich should give their wealth away while alive, building “ladders” people could climb.

    Andrew Carnegie, The Gospel of Wealth, 1889 (opens the source)
  10. 1913

    The modern foundation

    The Rockefeller Foundation set the model: perpetual, professional, “the well-being of mankind”.

    The Rockefeller Foundation, Charter, 1913 (opens the source)
  11. 1917

    The tax deduction

    The US made gifts tax-deductible so wartime tax rates would not cut giving by the rich.

    Crandall-Hollick, The Charitable Deduction for Individuals: A Brief Legislative History, 2020 (opens the source)
  12. 2010

    The Giving Pledge

    The world's richest were invited to promise most of their wealth to charity, in life or by will.

    The Giving Pledge, About the Pledge, 2010 (opens the source)
  13. 2045

    Giving while living

    The Gates Foundation plans to spend about US$200bn and close by 2045: Carnegie's idea at a new scale.

    Associated Press, Gates Foundation will close in 2045, via PBS NewsHour, 2025 (opens the source)

Scroll sideways for more.

Who we learn from.

Every finding on this page belongs to someone. These are the 75 researchers, organisations and texts it credits, each linked to the original. Where an organisation has a logo it is shown; otherwise the PhilaNova building mark stands in.

Further reading: Thierry Lombard (initiator), with Jestin, Ricard, Ward, Eichenberger and Machenbaum, Philanthropie : l'art de donner. Pourquoi les autres ? (opens the source) · Matthieu Ricard, Altruism, 2015 (opens the source) · Francie Ostrower, Why the Wealthy Give, 1995 (opens the source).

Why PhilaNova publishes this for free.

A public layer for philanthropy

The record of who funds what, the research behind giving, and one search across all of it. Free for anyone to read and use.

Tools for the people who advise

Private tools that help banks, family offices and foundations turn that open record into better decisions for their clients.